Just wanted to follow up that using --headless did the trick, which is also why it had been working previously. Thanks for the help!

Update:

Ran 1.10.1 just fine. Seems to be isolated to v2 for me. As this was working for me last week, I know I could just reinstall the OS, but I rather try to figure this out. 

Tried updating my Java to 1.8.0_131, but still getting the same error.