I'll leave this up but I ended up just rescanning and pulling my theme back over from my backup. 

I use 2.1.1 and this theme. More details about what you're experiencing?

Thanks Telecart, that's what I wound up doing. I will definitely try to contribute to the GitHub. That's all new to me!

I was able to work around this issue by maxing out the number of items per page, but I feel like there's got to be another resolution?

Is anyone else having issues with Featured Publishers not showing up? I think it's only showing the publishers who appear on the first page of my list. I'm far from proficient in any kind of coding so sorry if I'm missing something obvious.